Welcome to Cafe Amalfi Restaurant
**About Cafe Amalfi Restaurant**
Nestled in Sarasota, Florida, Cafe Amalfi Restaurant offers a delightful taste of authentic Italian cuisine. This charming eatery is known for its thin-crust pizzas, which strike the perfect balance of texture and flavor, featuring hearty, fresh toppings like exquisite mushrooms. The owner, a warm Italian host, ensures each dish is crafted with care, from the mouthwatering antipasto to the indulgent Eggplant Parmesan. With prompt and friendly service, diners can enjoy a cozy atmosphere, perfect for family nights or lunch breaks. Discovering Cafe Amalfi feels like finding a hidden gem, a must-visit for any food lover in the area!
Cafe Amalfi Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings
We do family pizza night every Saturday and thought we had been to every place in town. We were surprised to learn of Cafe Amalfi and on a tip from a stranger we gave it a try. We dropped in on a Saturday at about 8p and there were only 2 other tables seated so it was quiet. The service was really good (pretty sure he was the owner). The food came out super quick, almost surprising fast, yet it was perfectly cooked. The pizza crust was thin, but not too thin, it was just thick enough to give nice stability but not so dough’ie that you felt stuffed after one piece. The crust flavor was outstanding. The fresh mushrooms were the best we’ve ever had on a pie, hearty slices so they didn’t cook down to mush. French fries were good too, steak fries. It’s not a complaint, but a comment, the French Fry appetizer portion is kinda small. We ended up with like 15 to 18 fries per order so keep that in mind based on the size of your group and passion to crush fries. All in all, great find and we’ll certainly visit again.
We visited here this afternoon for lunch. We've talked about visiting for quite a while but haven't had the time to drop in. Well after today we are SUPER glad we stopped and ate because it was delicious and everything was very authentic. Restaurant at first appearance walking in was much nicer than expected and the owner took great care of us. The Antipasto was perfect with plenty of meat and just the right amount of greens. (Very little). The Stromboli's were delicious and my wife's fried Eggplant parmesan was to die for according to her. Please go check out this locally owned restaurant and you won't be disappointed! Thank you for the great experience, delicious food and authenticity!
Now that's an awesome mazzarella stick! And the pizza was even better. This is a must try if your in siesta key fl. The food is fantastic. Thanks John for making great food and offering perfect service.
This is Old Italy style - very authentic, delicious, and uses the best ingredients. The owner is a warm, friendly Italian man that really takes pride in his craft. The Margherita pizza was DIVINE. I'll be a regular when in Sarasota!
Omg ...... I wish I would’ve found this place sooner. It is amazing..... JOHN, the owner is straight out of brooklyne!! delicious food and top notch Service.. :) Lily Mae, our server was so friendly and efficient.... Highly Recommend
John makes us feel like family as if we’re back in Eastchester, NY. A breath of fresh air down here in Sarasota. We’ve been searching for true NY pizza since moving to SWFL over 2 years ago. Finally found it! John’s pizza is definitely authentic NY style. What a great find!!!! Thanks for a great experience! Highly recommend.
What a surprise. Ordered via Grubhub, had an itch for some calamari, was just hoping for something good. What I got was GREAT ! Calamari & Chicken Marsala done right !
Fabulous local place with all home made food. Pizza is great . Had home made pasta tonight for the first time it was amazing. Small place and the owner cooks for you. Can't find that very often. Give it a try and support a local. You we leave full and happy.
Location
-
1880 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231, United States Hotline: +1 941-922-7069
Welcome to Cafe Amalfi Restaurant, a delightful culinary gem nestled at 1880 Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34231. This charming establishment is a true embodiment of authentic Italian cuisine, serving up dishes that have already garnered a passionate following among locals and visitors alike.
Cafe Amalfi stands out in the competitive dining scene of Sarasota, not only for its cozy atmosphere but also for the genuine warmth exuded by its owner, John, who brings a slice of Brooklyn with him. Patrons rave about the attentive service and personal touch that elevate each dining experience. Reviewers describe the ambiance as unexpectedly inviting, making it a perfect spot for family gatherings, romantic dinners, or casual lunches.
One of the restaurant's highlights is undoubtedly its pizza. Guests have lauded the thin yet sturdy crust, striking a perfect balance that prevents it from feeling too doughy after just one piece. The quality of the ingredients shines through, especially the fresh mushrooms and the delightful flavor of the Margherita pizza, which one visitor deemed “DIVINE.” With each bite, you can taste the care that goes into its creation.
Beyond pizza, the diverse menu showcases an array of authentic Italian dishes. From perfectly curated antipasto platters brimming with high-quality meats to mouthwatering Strombolis and fried Eggplant Parmesan, there is something for everyone. Reviewers mention the delicious mozzarella sticks, and the steak fries have earned their share of praise, albeit with a gentle suggestion for slightly larger portions.
As you walk into Cafe Amalfi, you'll immediately sense that this is more than just a restaurant; it's a culinary journey through the heart of Italy, guided by passionate chefs and a genuinely friendly staff. Whether you’re new to Sarasota or a long-time resident, make sure to discover the impeccable flavors and warm hospitality that await you at Cafe Amalfi. You won't leave disappointed!
For inquiries and reservations, you can reach Cafe Amalfi at +1 941-922-7069. Don't miss out on this local favorite—where every meal is crafted with love and dedication!